How I Build Paywalls That PRINT ($44k/Month App)

Steven Cravotta| 00:16:22|Mar 24, 2026
Chapters8
An overview of the five steps to design and optimize paywalls for higher conversions and revenue.

Steven Cravotta reveals a repeatable five-step framework for paywalls that convert installs into paying users, backed by AB testing, market research tools, and rapid experimentation with Superwall.

Summary

Steven Cravotta shares the exact framework he used to scale his mobile app to $40k/month in recurring revenue, emphasizing no-code feasibility and heavy AB testing. He starts with market research using PaywallScreens.com and Sensor Tower to benchmark top apps in your niche. Cravotta then describes commissioning a high-conversion paywall via a 99designs contest, highlighting cost, breadth of design options, and the importance of a strong brief. He introduces Superwall as the core testing platform to iterate paywalls without shipping updates. The five-step process he outlines focuses on clear value propositions, social proof, optimal timing and onboarding, pricing tests, and button/header copy. He stresses that onboarding and ad quality largely drive paywall success, and that you should test everything in small, controlled increments following the scientific method. Finally, he introduces more advanced optimizations like drip funnels to recapture value from non-converters. Cravotta also shares personal results, including increasing initial conversion rates from 8.5% to nearly 25% and achieving substantial monthly revenue with minimal coding.

Key Takeaways

  • Use market benchmarking with PaywallScreens.com and Sensor Tower to identify top-performing paywalls in your niche and model your design after proven winners.
  • Commission a 99designs contest for a single paywall screen to access dozens of concepts; Cravotta paid $600 and received 91 designs.
  • Test paywall pricing aggressively (weekly, monthly, yearly, lifetime) to optimize for highest lifetime value (LTV) rather than intuition.
  • Optimize onboarding so users spend 5–10 minutes inside the app before the paywall appears, increasing willingness to convert.
  • Refine header copy and button text on the paywall; even small wording changes can boost conversion by single-digit percentages.
  • Use Superwall to run countless A/B tests on paywall elements (pricing, header, images, social proof) without app updates.
  • Implement drip funnels for non-converters by sending targeted push offers (e.g., 30–70% off) to recover lost value from a 70% abandon rate.

Who Is This For?

Essential viewing for mobile app founders and product teams who want a repeatable, data-driven approach to building profitable paywalls without heavy dev work. The video is especially valuable for those already looping through onboarding optimization and looking to monetize more effectively.

Notable Quotes

"I've cracked the code into building paywalls that don't just show up, they convert users into paying customers consistently."
Cravotta asserts the核心 outcome of his framework.
"We started at 8.5% initial conversion rate... and we went all the way up to close to a 25% initial conversion rate."
Shows tangible improvement from testing.
"Superwall is an absolutely crucial tool to use because you can run different experiments on your paywalls within your app."
Underscores the central tool for experimentation.
"Pricing... you always want to test your pricing. For example, test out weekly, monthly, yearly, and lifetime options."
Highlights the pricing-strategy topic.
"Dripfunnels... if the people don't convert on your paywall, you send them a push notification that says, 'Hey, get 30, 50, 70% off'... that’s a cheat code."
Describes a recovery tactic for lost conversions.

Questions This Video Answers

  • How can I validate a mobile app paywall without shipping updates?
  • What is the best way to use AB testing for paywalls in iOS/Android apps?
  • Which tools help you benchmark paywalls and optimize onboarding for higher conversions?
  • What pricing models maximize LTV for subscription apps?
  • What are drip funnels and how do they improve paywall revenue for non-converters?
PaywallScreens.comSensor Tower99designsSuperwallA/B TestingOnboarding OptimizationPricing StrategyLifetime ValueDrip FunnelsMobile App Monetization
Full Transcript
If you've clicked on this video, it's probably because you've got an app idea, or maybe you even have an app up and running, but you're simply not seeing the revenue numbers that you would like. Maybe you're struggling to make your payw wall actually convert. And trust me, I've been there, too. But after testing hundreds of different variations [music] of pay walls, I've cracked the code into building payw walls that don't just show up, they convert users into paying customers consistently. In today's video, I'm going to walk you through my [music] exact framework for building pay walls that drive revenue. These are the exact strategies that allowed me to scale my mobile app to $40,000 in monthly recurring revenue. And the best part is they're easy to implement with no coding experience required. Just to show you how important AB testing and optimizing [music] your onboarding and payw wall are, here is the initial conversion rate aka conversion rate from [music] install to trial or subscription. Here is that conversion rate over the 5 months that we AV tested the payw walls and onboarding. We started at [music] 8.5% initial conversion rate. That is trash. And we went all the way up to close to a 25% [music] initial conversion rate. We became three times more profitable just by implementing the things [music] I'm going to show you in this video. So, be sure to watch until the end of it because I'm going to be dropping so much knowledge in this video. I have absolutely nothing to sell you. I'm just going to show you exactly how I build app payw walls that print cash. Okay. Boom. Here we are. This blueprint will be in the description if you want to follow through. But I have broken this down into a simple five-step process that absolutely anyone can follow. If you follow these five steps, your payw wall will convert more installs to free trials, more installs to subscriptions. Each one of these points is is super super important. So, let's kick things off with market research. There is one website that is an absolute cheat code in terms of looking at other apps payw walls and that is paywallscreens.com. So you can go here on a paywallcreens.com and you can literally see all of the top performing apps payw walls and they will tell you how much each one of these apps is making. So for example, we have YouTube's payw wall, Tik Tok's payw wall. These aren't really very useful to us, but they also break it down into categories. So you can go to utility apps, right? You can also search so you can find the apps in your niche. So, let's go to health and fitness, for example, and boom, you can see the pay walls of these apps making $10 million, $8 million, $6 million every single month. You literally have insight into what the top apps are doing, right? So, definitely check out this website. Go search up your niche and learn what the other top performing apps are doing. A lot of these will have similar similar style payw walls. For example, these two are making $2 million a month each and they have a very similar style, right? They offer three different plans on your payw walls. So, go to paywallscreens.com and do a little bit of market research and learn something from the people who do it best. And as always, we have Sensor Tower as well. Sensor Tower is a place where you can also see how much these apps are making every single month. For example, let's check out this muscle booster app. WellTech Apps Limited is the name. So, we can type that in right here. Boom. And we can see that indeed their muscle booster app is making about a million dollars a month. Sensor tower says $800,000. Pay wall screen says a million a month, but this payw wall absolutely crushes. So, take this knowledge, do some market research, and use it in your own payw wall. Okay, now that we've done the market research and we understand what payw walls in our niche are doing very well because we looked at payw wall screens and sensor tower, we can start to design the payw walls. And the way I get this done, and if you're if you've been on the channel for a minute, you know what I'm going to say is 99 designs, right? So, how I got my payw wall built was a 99 designs contest. This was the winning payw wall uh from a guy that I know very well named Zach, the absolute best designer in the world. So, this is the payw wall that he built for me and he actually had a couple different options here, but this payw wall absolutely crushes. And again, I did the market research on uh sensor tower and on paywall screens so I knew what was going to work well for my app. I'll break down kind of exactly what my brief on 99 designs looked like. Yeah. So, here we go. in in the inspirational websites, I literally put paywallscreens.com and I referenced the health and fitness niche, uh, which is an invalid input now, but I literally referenced these payw walls in my 99s contest to kind of give them a little bit of direction on what I needed. And then I explained my app a little bit um, and ran the contest. So, if you want to build one of these 99 design contests for yourself, it's very straightforward. We go to web and app design. App design. We will run a contest for a single screen. Boom. So, if you start an app contest for a single screen, it will cost you $600, which is a little bit pricey, but I promise you it is worth it because in a 99 designs contest, you will get so many different designs. Uh, for example, in my contest, I got over 91 different designs from different designers, right? Um, and I was able to pick the best one, which as you saw was this one. But I was able to get 99 different designs built all for the price of $600, which is worth it in my opinion because the payw wall is very important to the success of your app. Also, Superwall is a website that I will be referencing a lot in this video. Superwall is a place where you can quickly build and test pay walls without shipping updates. And what that means is you can remotely change your payw wall without shipping an app update. It is so much quicker and it will give you all the tools to AB test your different payw walls. So as you can see here, I had AB tested close to 100 different payw walls for my app. And Superwall is an absolutely crucial tool to use because you can run different experiments on your payw walls within your app, right? and you can increase the conversion rate over time. So you you can see here that I've run all sorts of different experiments here which we will get into shortly. So kind of some design best practices that you need to keep in mind is clarity is very important. Clarity over complexity on the payw wall screen. You don't want to overload the user's mind. Make it very sweet and simple. For example, on the puff count payw wall, I keep it very straight and forward. Track how much you smoke or track how many puffs you take. Track your usage. very straightforward, very easy to understand. What is that one headline? What is the one benefit that people will get from using your app. The whole goal here in designing your payw wall is to get a user to convert as quick as possible. You want to highlight the value proposition. For example, mine is track how much you smoke. And then you also want social proof and trust indicators here. For example, we have some fivestar reviews from our users on the payw wall itself. And next, we will get into positioning your payw wall. When should you show your payw wall? What is the best time to show your payw wall and how can you prime the user before hitting your payw wall to convert a little bit better, right? And something that is very important to keep in mind when you are building your payw wall and uh thinking about your app from a more general high level is the conversion starts from the very beginning. The conversion starts from the ad or the piece of content that the user saw before they downloaded your app. So how good your ads or your content is will kind of influence how your payw wall converts, right? But with a better piece of content, with a better paid ad, your payw wall will convert better, right? Also, with an onboarding app, a better onboarding experience in your app will also make your payw wall convert better. Timing is absolutely everything as well because you want users to spend a little bit of time in your app before they actually hit your payw wall. If someone downloads your app and then immediately they're met with a payw wall screen and they're they have they have to choose between paying or not paying, they're not going to pay. They're going to pay at a much lower rate than they would if they already spent time in your app. So the onboarding is absolutely crucial. Here's exactly what I mean by the onboarding and priming your user for the payw wall. For example, this is just fits onboarding. If we go here and we search for the Just Fit app, this app is making $2 million every single month. And here is their entire onboarding. They walk you through, you know, what your goal is. They they ask you to fill out some body data. They ask you to input information about yourself. And then boom, they have social proof at the end. And only after all of that do they give you the payw wall. That's absurd. Timing is absolutely crucial. And the onboarding is absolutely crucial when it comes to the success of your payw wall. You want users to spend time in your app. You want to walk the users through their own problem on your onboarding so that when they do hit the payw wall, they've spent 5 10 minutes in your app. There's like that sunk cost bias that they spent time. they've been walked through their their own problem and they are ready to convert once they hit your payw wall. What this app also does very well is that there's this feeling of customization, right? As you're walking through this onboarding, you're building your own custom fitness plan that adds a layer of customization to the app. It makes you feel like it's yours, right, as a user. And again, you know, we have another one here. This is fit at home. Let's type that one in. Fitness at home. Boom. See, all these apps are making $100,000 a month. Absolutely crazy. And then we have 30-day fitness at home. This app as well, this app is making $100,000 a month, right? So, these apps are absolutely crushing it. This is research that I did when building my apps payw wall and onboarding. Right? You need to keep this in mind and look at your app's payw wall from a higher level. Right? Because there's other things affecting it like the ads and the onboarding and the timing. Right? You want to prime the user to be ready to convert when they hit the payw wall. All right. Now, we're getting into the good stuff. So, be sure to continue to stick around because this is the most important part of a payw wall and it is AB testing your payw wall. And this is why Superwall is such an amazing tool for app developers because AB testing every single little element in your payw wall is the most important part. If you change the text of a button or you change the text of the headline, right, you will be shocked at how much this will increase your conversion rate. For example, on PuffC count, I got a tip from a friend to change some wording on the the pay button on my payw wall and increase my conversion rate by 7% overnight. So, this is absolutely important and Superwall is what you need to use to be AB testing everything in your payw wall. So, I'm going to get into how to do that right now and what to be AB testing on your pay walls. Real quick, if you're enjoying the video, I'm hosting a free live class where I'll be covering absolutely everything about scaling a successful mobile app. From idea validation to building the app to scaling to real recurring revenue and eventually being able to sell or exit your app business. I will be covering absolutely everything in this free live class. And by the way, spots are limited. So check out the link in the description if you want to join. I promise you'll walk away with value. Okay, back to the video. Okay, so AB testing your payw wall. This is where this is one of the rare moments where school paid off because I know we all remember learning about the scientific method in school. You need to apply the scientific method to your payw walls. You can't change a million things and uh you know you can't change a million things at once and expect to know what change affected the pay walls conversion rate if that makes sense. So you can only change one thing at a time. So breaking this down a little bit further, the most important thing that you want to test for at first is the pricing. And when you are pricing your mobile app, you always want to go higher than you think. It feels weird to charge a lot for your mobile app. I know that like it it just feels weird to do so, but always charging more will increase your revenue. I promise you that. Just trust me there. So, you always want to test your pricing. For example, what you should do to test your pricing is test out weekly, monthly, yearly, and lifetime kind of options, right? You want to figure out which one of those is going to make you the most cash. So, what you can do at first is you can give the users a couple different options. This is what I did at first, right? I gave them a weekly, monthly, yearly, whatever, whatever I I gave them, right? And I figured out which one gave me the highest customer LTD. That is what you want to optimize for. You want to optimize for the highest LTV or lifetime value each one of your customers. And it's going to be different from every for every different app. It depends on kind of how users operate in your app and, you know, how useful they see your app is and you know, whether they renew, right? It's going to be different for everyone. So, you can't look at someone else's app and just assume that that's what's going to work for you. You have to AB test absolutely everything. So, use Superwall. Uh they will actually give you a Beijian analysis of, you know, which kind of payw wall converts the best and they will tell you which pricing will give you the highest LTV, right? So, you want to optimize for the for the pricing. And then what you also want to do is optimize the header wording. this right here, whatever you have on the top of your payw wall, this will also definitely kind of alter the conversion rate of your payw wall as well. For example, this just fit app that is making $2 million a month. They say get your personalized plan. They have nice images here. You know, these these images and this this header wording, you know, that will definitely uh increase your conversion rate as well. And you want to test different things. You don't want to just test the same things like I would test quit for real this time and track how much you smoke and a lot of other different things, right? You want to test vastly different headers to kind of get yourself closer to the most optimized header wording possible. And then finally, you want to optimize the button text. For example, this one says continue. And you want to you want to test out the different uh button text versions as well. You want to run these different campaigns and it will tell you which payw wall is converting the highest. So once you've run kind of the scientific method and you've AB tested absolutely everything on your payw wall header images you know social proof the button text the pricing itself once you have optimized absolutely everything for conversions and the highest LTV on your payw wall. You also want to optimize the onboarding and keep in mind I dropped an amazing onboarding video a couple months ago that will show you exactly how to build a killer app onboarding and AB test your onboarding. But this is also very important for your payw wall. will affect whether your payw wall converts or not. So with the onboarding, you want to get users to spend more time in the app so that that when they do hit your payw wall, they've already spent time and they feel more committed to your app so they'll be more likely to pay and you want to optimize the app onboarding for the PE number of people who convert at your payw wall. And then also on the paid ad side of things, if you change your paid ads, if your paid ads are bad, your payw wall will convert less. If your paid ads are better, your payw wall will convert better, right? So you want to optimize that for payw wall conversions as well. You can set up events in your paid ads and you want to say, "Hey, I want to optimize for people who are actually going to convert into a free trial." That's what I did uh to scale my apps. Finally, dripfunnels. This is a bit more complex on the development side of things, but what you can do is offer a dripfunnel campaign. And what that means is if the people don't convert on your payw wall, for example, on, you know, our pay walls, we have the conversion rate was anywhere from like 20 to like 30%, right? For that 70% of people who don't convert, that is lost value. And what you can do to make up and capture some of that lost value is you can offer a dripfunnel campaign. And what this means is if a user doesn't convert or they abandon their payw wall, you send them a push notification that says, "Hey, get 30, 50, 70% off of my app, right? And then if they click on that, you offer them a discounted payw wall." This is an absolute cheat code because those 70% of users, you're going to lose them anyway. So, you might as well offer them a large discount to try to capture some of that value. That will make your app more profitable. It will allow you to run more paid ads and scale a little bit further. Boom. You are now a PayWall expert. We went through all five steps of optimizing your payw wall. If you stayed until the end of the video, you probably enjoyed it. I would definitely appreciate a like. And if you want to see more of me dropping value for absolutely free, please consider subscribing. It would mean the absolute world to me. Hope you enjoy. Please actually put this into practice. Don't just watch this video and and you know not take action on this. Please try everything that I mentioned in this video and I promise it will increase your conversion rate. If you have any questions or you want to ask me something, be sure to hit me up on Instagram. I am super active there. I will always get back to you in the DMs. Hope you enjoyed the video and peace.

Get daily recaps from
Steven Cravotta

AI-powered summaries delivered to your inbox. Save hours every week while staying fully informed.